Skip to main content

Obama leading all Midwest states in Big Ten Battleground Poll

Oct. 23, 2008

“In September, we saw virtually the entire Big Ten as a battleground. Now Obama is clearly winning the Big Ten battleground. The dominance of the economy as a top issue for voters is the overwhelming story.”

Charles Franklin
University of Wisconsin-Madison

As the race for the White House enters its final days, the Big Ten Battleground Poll shows Barack Obama holding double-digit leads over John McCain in eight crucial Midwest states.

The individual surveys of between 562 and 586 randomly selected registered voters and those likely to register to vote before the election in each of the states were conducted by phone with live interviewers from Oct. 19-22 and were co-directed by University of Wisconsin-Madison political scientists Charles Franklin and Ken Goldstein with the cooperation of colleagues from participating Big Ten universities. The polls each have a margin of error of 4.2 percentage points. The states included in the poll were Ohio, Michigan, Pennsylvania, Indiana, Wisconsin, Iowa, Illinois and Minnesota, home to the 11 universities in the Big Ten conference.

Those states were key battlegrounds in the 2004 election, and last month the Big Ten Battleground Poll showed a tight race in all of those states but Illinois, which Obama represents in the U.S. Senate.

The first poll was taken two days before Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson announced the need for a massive bailout of Wall Street – when McCain was enjoying his highest poll numbers of the campaign in the Big Ten and nationally. The October survey was taken after the financial crisis worsened and following debates between the presidential and vice presidential candidates.

“In September, we saw virtually the entire Big Ten as a battleground,” said Franklin, co-developer of Pollster.com. “Now Obama is clearly winning the Big Ten battleground. The dominance of the economy as a top issue for voters is the overwhelming story.”

The new Big Ten poll shows Obama ahead in every Big Ten state, including Indiana, where McCain held a slight edge in September and a Democrat has not won since 1964. Obama also leads in Ohio and Pennsylvania, where last month’s poll results showed the two candidates in a dead heat.

“McCain was gaining until the financial crisis hit,” Franklin said. “Once the crisis hit, support moved from McCain to Obama.”

Head-to-head results for individual states

IllinoisObama 61%McCain 32%
IndianaObama 51%McCain 41%
IowaObama 52%McCain 39%
MichiganObama 58%McCain 36%
MinnesotaObama 57%McCain 38%
OhioObama 53%McCain 41%
PennsylvaniaObama 52%McCain 41%
WisconsinObama 53%McCain 40%

The poll also included a nationally representative sample of 1,014 respondents, with a margin of error of 3.1 percentage points. That survey shows Obama with a 9-point margin over McCain, 52 percent to 43 percent.

“With the fundamental factors so to their advantage, this election was always about Barack Obama and the Democrats reaching a threshold level of credibility with voters,” Goldstein said. “It appears Obama has and this race has popped nationally and here in the Big Ten.”

Sixty percent of voters in the national survey think Obama is better able to bring about change, while 28 percent hold that view about McCain; 7 in 10 said McCain was more experienced.

The voters’ views of Republican vice presidential nominee Sarah Palin have dimmed in the month since the first Big Ten poll. In September, half of voters in the national poll held a favorable view of the Alaska governor and 37 percent viewed her unfavorably. In the new poll, 44 percent of voters hold a favorable view of Palin and 48 percent have an unfavorable view.

The national survey also shows deep voter dissatisfaction with the current administration and the federal government. Two-thirds of voters hold an unfavorable view of President George W. Bush and just 20 percent said they trust the federal government to do what is right all or most of the time. More than 8 in 10 voters said the country is on the wrong track.

In the national survey, 63 percent of voters named the economy and jobs as the most important problem facing the country today and 91 percent think the economy has gotten worse in the last year. Eleven percent of voters said their top issue was terrorism and national security; 7 percent named health care and just 5 percent said the Iraq War.

The sample of registered voters and those likely to register to vote before the 2008 Presidential election – because several Big Ten states have same-day registration – for the state and national surveys was selected by random digit dialing (RDD) of landline phones. Cell-only households were not included in the sample.

The results of this rare regional poll -- a partnership involving eight Big Ten universities – will be featured during a 90-minute show called Big Ten Battleground: Campaign 2008, which airs at 3 p.m. CDT (4 p.m. EDT) today (Oct. 23) on the Big Ten Network.

Universities participating in the partnership are the University of Illinois, the University of Iowa, the University of Michigan, Michigan State University, Northwestern University, Ohio State University, Penn State University and UW-Madison.

For news media

View a list of faculty from Big Ten universities participating in the poll who are available to media for comment on the poll results.

Media contacts
Dennis Chaptman, University Communications, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 608-262-9406,

Jenny Price, University Communications, University of Wisconsin-Madison, 608-262-8296,

Poll results

Margin: +/- 4%
(Mouse over states for results.)
Map showing presidential eleciont poll results from Oct. 23 in each Big Ten state Pennsylvania Ohio Indiana Illinois Iowa Minnesota Wisconsin Michigan
Illinois
Obama: 61%
McCain: 32%
Indiana
Obama: 51%
McCain: 41%
Iowa
Obama: 52%
McCain: 39%
Michigan
Obama: 58%
McCain: 36%
Minnesota
Obama: 57%
McCain: 38%
Ohio
Obama: 53%
McCain: 41%
Pennsylvania
Obama: 52%
McCain: 41%
Wisconsin
Obama: 53%
McCain: 40%
McCain
Red square map key symbol for McCainStrong - 0
Pink square map key symbol for leaning McCainLean - 0

Yellow square map key symbol for tieToss up - 0
Obama
Blue square map key symbol for ObamaStrong - 8
Light blue square map key symbol for ObamaLean - 0

View complete poll results for each state, including responses to issues-based questions »

Map showing presidential eleciont poll results in each Big Ten state Pennsylvania Ohio Indiana Illinois Iowa Minnesota Wisconsin Michigan
Illinois
Obama: 53%
McCain: 37%
Indiana
Obama: 43%
McCain: 47%
Iowa
Obama: 45%
McCain: 45%
Michigan
Obama: 48%
McCain: 44%
Minnesota
Obama: 47
McCain: 45%
Ohio
Obama: 46%
McCain: 45%
Pennsylvania
Obama: 45%
McCain: 45%
Wisconsin
Obama: 45%
McCain: 44%
McCain
Red square map key symbol for McCainStrong - 0
Pink square map key symbol for leaning McCainLean - 1

Yellow square map key symbol for tieToss up - 6
Obama
Blue square map key symbol for ObamaStrong - 1
Light blue square map key symbol for ObamaLean - 0

View complete poll results for each state, including responses to issues-based questions »

Video: Expert analysis

Watch video on the Web from Big Ten Battleground: Campaign 2008, a Big Ten Network television program about the poll results that features Big Ten faculty experts with first-hand knowledge of the dynamics of the race in their respective states.
Watch »

Past news releases

Related media coverage